Emergency Management

When code minimums aren't enough

Achieving true emergency preparedness requires healthcare facilities to exceed strict regulatory compliance
|

Healthcare facilities operate in one of the most highly regulated environments in the nation. Codes, standards and regulatory requirements establish a baseline for safety and provide a framework for surveyors to evaluate compliance. Yet, one of the most important lessons facilities leaders and emergency managers can learn is that meeting the minimum requirement does not always mean the intended outcome has been achieved.

In many areas of healthcare operations, it is easy to become focused on compliance. Facilities and emergency management leaders review regulations, update policies, prepare documentation and verify that required elements are present. While these activities are important, they sometimes can shift attention away from a more fundamental question: Will they actually work when needed most?

Challenges in emergency management resilience and readiness offer a prime example of why this question lingers for many leaders.

Compliance is not the same as preparedness

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Emergency Preparedness Rule, which is included in the Conditions of Participation, provides clear expectations regarding what organizations must include in their emergency management programs. Facilities are required to conduct risk assessments, develop emergency plans, provide staff training, perform exercises and maintain supporting documentation.

These requirements serve an important purpose. They create a consistent framework for surveyors to evaluate whether an organization has the basic components of an emergency management program in place.

However, the regulations are not intended to be a comprehensive guide for managing every aspect of a real-world emergency. They establish a minimum threshold for compliance, not a guarantee of operational effectiveness.

An organization may successfully meet every survey requirement and still discover significant gaps when confronted with an actual disaster, infrastructure failure, mass casualty incident or communitywide emergency.

One challenge with many regulatory requirements is that they tend to focus heavily on planning, documentation, training and exercises. These elements are critical, but they often represent only a portion of what is required to successfully navigate a major event.

True emergency preparedness extends across the entire continuum of an incident:

  • Pre-event planning,
  • Mitigation and prevention activities,
  • Response operations,
  • Recovery and restoration,
  • Business continuity, 
  • Reentry and resumption of normal operations, and
  • After-action improvement efforts. 

If an organization focuses solely on what is required for a survey, it may overlook important considerations that emerge before, during and after the event itself.

The value of looking beyond CMS requirements

The National Fire Protection Association’s NFPA 99, Health Care Facilities Code, provides a useful illustration of how organizations can expand their thinking about preparedness beyond meeting minimum regulatory requirements.

While often viewed primarily as a medical gas and healthcare facilities code, NFPA 99 includes important concepts related to emergency management. The standard emphasizes maintaining essential clinical support activities, identifying critical utility needs, defining staff responsibilities, assessing medical surge capabilities and evaluating the effectiveness of emergency plans through testing and exercises.

These considerations help healthcare organizations better understand how patient care can be maintained during adverse conditions.

Yet even NFPA 99 is only one piece of the larger preparedness ecosystem.

A broader emergency management perspective through NFPA 1660

Organizations seeking to develop truly resilient emergency management programs should consider broader guidance, such as NFPA 1660, Standard for Emergency, Continuity, and Crisis Management: Preparedness, Response, and Recovery.

NFPA 1660 addresses areas that often are only briefly mentioned or not addressed at all, in regulatory requirements. These include:

  • Business continuity planning,
  • Crisis management,
  • Mass evacuation strategies,
  • Sheltering operations,
  • Recovery and reentry processes,
  • Multiorganizational coordination,
  • First responder integration, and
  • Community and regional partnerships.

These topics become critically important during large-scale events, yet they may not receive significant attention during a compliance-focused program review.

For example, a facility may have documented evacuation procedures sufficient to satisfy survey expectations. However, an effective evacuation strategy also requires transportation coordination, receiving facility agreements, patient tracking systems, staffing continuity plans, security considerations, supply chain contingencies and regional response coordination.

These are the types of operational details that often determine whether a response succeeds or struggles.

The goal is compliance plus readiness 

Compliance should never be viewed as the finish line. Instead, it should be viewed as the starting point. Healthcare facilities exist to provide care during some of the most challenging circumstances imaginable. Patients, staff and communities depend on hospitals to remain operational when emergencies occur. Achieving that level of resilience requires broader thinking than simply meeting the minimum regulatory requirements.

The most effective emergency managers understand that surveys measure compliance, while real events measure capability. Both are important, but they are not the same thing. Organizations that expand their perspective beyond individual regulations and embrace the broader emergency management ecosystem are better positioned to identify vulnerabilities, strengthen response capabilities and improve continuity of operations.

Codes and regulations establish an essential foundation for safety and preparedness. They help ensure consistency, accountability and a common baseline across healthcare organizations. However, minimum requirements are exactly that: minimum requirements.

When developing emergency management programs, facilities leaders should continually ask whether their efforts are preparing the organization to pass a survey or preparing the organization to successfully manage an actual emergency.

The answer always should be both.

The facilities that perform best during crises are rarely those that focus solely on compliance. They are the organizations that understand the intent behind the requirements, look beyond the minimum standards and build programs designed not just to satisfy a surveyor, but to protect patients, staff and operations when it matters most.


Chad Beebe, AIA, CHFM, CFPS, CBO, FASHE, is deputy executive director of ASHE Regulatory Affairs.

Related Articles